A public hearing on controversial plans to charge drivers a fee to enter Manhattan’s busiest areas will be held next week in Westchester.
The meeting will be held at 6 p.m., Thursday at the Westchester County Center at 198 Central Ave. in White Plains. It take places in meeting rooms A-B on the first floor.
Five public hearings will be held in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Staten Island, Queens and Long Island at the same time on the same night. A public hearing was held in Manhattan last night.
There are five proposals under consideration, each of which could be implemented as they stand or in some combination:
• New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s original vision, in which cars would pay $8 and trucks $21 to travel south of 86th Street between 6 a.m. and 6 p.m. weekdays. Those traveling through Manhattan on the West Side Highway or the FDR Drive would not pay a fee. The plan would generate $420 million, but it has high operating costs and could hurt low- and moderate-income workers who drive into the city but don’t have mass-transit choices. The fees would be collected using a combination of E-ZPass tag readers and cameras taking pictures of license plates at hundreds of city entry points. It’s expected to reduce vehicle miles traveled by 6.7 percent.
• An alternative would reduce the size of the congestion-pricing zone, setting its north boundary at 60th Street and getting rid of the $4 fee for drivers traveling within the zone under Bloomberg’s plan. Metered parking rates would be increased, and a $1 taxi/livery surcharge would be added. The plan would generate $520 million a year, but all drivers, even those passing through Manhattan, would have to pay the fee. It would reduce vehicle miles traveled by 6.8 percent.
• Collecting tolls on the East River and Harlem River is also under consideration. Drivers would pay a $4 toll to enter and to leave Manhattan on 14 bridges, including the Henry Hudson Bridge. This plan would produce the most money for the city, $859 million a year, but because the tolls would be collected 24 hours a day, seven days a week, it would affect all drivers, even those who do not contribute to congestion. It would reduce vehicle miles traveled by 7 percent.
• Under a fourth plan, access to the busiest parts of Manhattan would be restricted based on the last digit of a vehicle’s license plate. This way, the city would be able to ban a vehicle once every five days. Certain vehicles would be exempt. The plan would not raise any money for mass transit, but would eliminate arguments that congestion pricing favored the well-off. It would reduce vehicle miles traveled by 10.3 percent.
• A fifth, combination plan would not reduce miles traveled by the required 6.3 percent, but some of its elements could be woven into the panel’s final recommendation. It would have increased the city’s parking tax from 18.4 percent to 38.4 percent, raised meter rates, reduced the number of government parking permits by 10,000, charged a $2 parking fee in the congestion zone and added an $8 surcharge for taxi trips that start or end south of 86th Street.
The New York City Traffic Congestion Mitigation Commission will meet Jan. 31 for the last time, when it will recommend a final proposal to the state Legislature. State lawmakers and the New York City Council must both approve a plan for it to take effect.
Here are the other hearing locations. Note that all of the meetings begin at 6 p.m., Thursday, Jan. 24.
• Medgar Evers College
1650 Bedford Avenue
Brooklyn
• College of Staten Island – Center for the Arts, Recital Hall 1P
2800 Victory Blvd
Staten Island
• Hostos Community College – Savoy Multi-purpose Room
120 Walton Avenue
Bronx
• York College Performing Arts Center
94-20 Guy R Brewer Blvd btw Liberty & Archer
Jamaica
• Hofstra University – University Club
(north of Main Gate)
Hempstead